The Ariel
Center for Policy Research (ACPR)

Archives for
The Jerusalem Cloakroom

Op-Eds
by
Yoram Ettinger

Contact Us

Jerusalem Cloakroom #151

THE JEWISH STATE AND A PALESTINIAN STATE:
MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE OR INCLUSIVE?

THE SECURITY SIGNIFICANCE of the
JUDEA & SAMARIA MOUNTAIN RIDGES

by Yoram Ettinger
yoramtex@netvision.net.il

March 12, 2004
 

Can the Jewish state survive a withdrawal from Judea, Samaria and Gaza – in the world's most brutal neighborhood where there has never been an inter-Arab peace - which would reduce Israel to a sliver waistline, shorter than the length of the Atlanta or Dallas-Ft. Worth airports?!

May Israel's leaders follow in the footsteps of Moses and Elijah, demolishing the Golden Calf and Idols of Oslo/Wye/RoadMap/ Unilateral Withdrawal, departing from short-lived wishful-thinking, and reconnecting with long-term Mideast and counter-terrorism realities.

Yoram

 

The Demise of Saddam Has NOT Waived the Threat to Israel

  • The Mideast is the world's most violent and unpredictable region, which requires preparedness for the worst-case scenario, including an Eastern Front assault on Israel.
     

  • In 1967 Israel crashed Egypt, Syria and Jordan, and grew over-confident that no Arab attack would be forthcoming. The 1973 War almost annihilated Israel.
     

  • Will the US be able to stabilize Iraq? Will Bush retreat from Iraq? Will his successor (in 2005 of 2009) retreat from Iraq? A US evacuation of Iraq could produce more terror than it intended to quell.

Judea and Samaria (J&S) Mountain Ridges: Irreplaceable for Israel's Security

  • "Land Warfare Papers", US Army (Oct. 2003): "The Gulf Wars (1991 and 2003) were not decided by bombs and missiles, but by ground forces."
     

  • Missiles cause damage; they don't bring enemies to submission. There is a marked difference between a barrage of missiles on Tel Aviv, and the invasion of Arab tanks to Tel Aviv.
     

  • The centrality of ground forces suggests the centrality of ground features (Topographic edge and geographic depth).
     

  • The eastern mountain ridge of J&S - rather than the Jordan Valley – constitutes the best tank obstacle in the world (3,000 feet steep slope, controllable by a small force).
     

  • The western mountain ridge of J&S (2,000 feet moderate slope overtowering Jerusalem, Tel Aviv and Haifa) constitutes an invader's dream platform. A withdrawal from J&S would submit the Jerusalem-Tel Aviv-Haifa area (80% of population) to daily terror.
     

  • The J&S mountain ridges constitute the "Golan Heights" of Israel's Soft Belly.
     

  • Until 1967 Israel limited Jordan's military presence in J&S to 5,000, lest it becomes a lethal threat. The 40,000 armed Palestinian terrorists in J&S amount to 4 brigades. A withdrawal from J&S would make a 1973-style surprise Arab attack a lethal threat.

Technology Cannot Replace Ground Features

  • High-tech today becomes low-tech tomorrow, but high-ground today remains high-ground tomorrow.
     

  • Every high-tech system is eventually outflanked by an emerging system. The dominant mountain ridges of J&S can never by outflanked by an emerging ground feature.
     

  • No nation alters its borders per technological developments.

The Bottom Line

  • Israel's margin of error is zero, and it must win every war. J&S mountain ridges constitute Israel's insurance policy against lethal human errors.
     

  • Is it logical to expect that the Arabs would accord to Israel that which they have denied each other (peace and compliance), while Israel shares with the Arabs that which it lacks (land)???